The two of you just staged this, in order to make it look like the Orthodox aren’t quite as monolithic as people were led to believe. Right?
My suspicion is you’re both totally in agreement on both counts. And yes, I think R’ Yitzchok didn’t see the comparison Jeff was making. But I’m not sure about R’ Yitzchok’s statement that “the State taking over and protecting kids” is something we should applaud.
How far does that go, before the state starts interfering with our own parental decision making?